202102.25

UDRP on noo.com: reverse domain name hijacking

JHO Intellectual Property Holdings and Elite IP Holdings are engaged in a promotional campaign for beverages and clothing that includes the term “NOO”. To this end, in the course of the year 2020, they have filed hundreds of trademarks around the world. However, deprived of the noo.com domain name, owned by Mr. T. since 2005, these two companies felt a loophole that they tried to fill by initiating a UDRP procedure to obtain the domain name.

However, the reckless complaint could hardly succeed. Indeed, the respondent had acquired the domain name 15 years before the first use of the claimants’ trademarks. UDRP case law provides recent examples of success many years after the registration or acquisition of the disputed domain name (kingofpop.com: Michael Jackson’s rights holders and other celebrities facing domain name issues, iptwins.com, 2019-07-11UDRP: transfer of Mandela.org to the guardians of Nelson Mandela’s memory, iptwins.com, 2019-07-27UDRP: stevejobs.com, transferred 20 years after registration, iptwins.com, 2019-12-20; ​​UDRP: pabloescobar.com, transferred 20 years after its registration, iptwins.com 2019-10-16). However, in these examples, claimants were in a position to prove that they had prior trademark rights. In this case, however, the claimants were unable to provide this proof. Therefore, given the circumstances, the respondent unmistakably could not have been aware of the “NOO” trademarks at the time of the registration of the domain name. As a result, it was unthinkable that the claimants would succeed in proving bad faith. Among other reasons, the sole panelist held the following:

“there is no evidence that Respondent has used the Domain Name in a manner that reflects bad faith. Respondent’s prior use of the Domain Name for various content on webpages linked to the Domain Name does not reflect any targeting of Complainants or their NOO marks”.

I can only agree on this, although there are discordant voices (see UDRP on iss.mobi: a transfer that does not go without saying, iptwins.com, 2021-02-05).

The facts show that the claimants knew or should have known that their claim was without merit for the respondent and the sole panelist. In other words, the complaint was abusive.


Source: WIPO, D2020-3504, JHO Intellectual Property Holdings, LLC, Elite IP Holdings LLC v. Mahad Taheri, February 16, 2021, <noo.com> (sole panelist: Christopher S. Gibson).

About IP TWINS

OUR SERVICES

1. Domain Names Management IP Twins is an accredited domain name registrar. — We help develop an appropriate domain name strategy and manage portfolios centrally and proactively. Thanks to our proprietary software, we identify cybersquatting cases in all TLDs. Our IP/IT lawyers deliver personalized reports. We may also advise or represent our clients in UDRP or other tldDRP proceedings.

2. Online Brand Protection Counterfeiting is everywhere online. — Nowadays, SMEs are also concerned. Our internal "Detective"​ software identifies the online use of your trademark by unauthorized third parties. We monitor on social networks and online market platforms, worldwide and in all languages. We submit reports on a periodic basis determined in agreement with the client and, where appropriate, we provide enforcement services.

OUR PHILOSOPHY — At IP Twins, we value the relationship with our partners. We nurture a human vision of our profession. Since the creation of IP Twins in 2002, our lawyers and developers have been working hand-in-hand to develop technologies, methods, and processes to ensure the reliability and accuracy of our services. That's why we have developed a variety of specific tools and this is also why our account managers are specialized IP/IT lawyers. Our tools, in constant improvement, are acclaimed by our clients, IP lawyers, and international partners. The reports and analysis we send considerably help them in their mission of domain name management and online brand protection both in the judicial and extrajudicial fields.

OUR CLIENTS — Our clients are law firms or industrial property consultants, companies of all sizes, local authorities, and organizations for the defense of geographical indications, in France and abroad.